The story revolves around Gillian Holroyd, a modern-day witch living in New York City, who becomes infatuated with her neighbor, Shep Henderson. Using her magical powers, she casts a spell to make him fall in love with her, complicating matters when she genuinely starts to care for him. As Gillian navigates the complexities of love and magic, she faces the dilemma of choosing between her supernatural abilities and the possibility of a normal life without them. The narrative explores themes of love, identity, and the sacrifices one makes for personal happiness.